Latched/Locked Door of Unit No.1151 – Coffee and Curry Puffs
In examination in chief, he explained that when he allegedly went into Unit Number 1151 (“the Unit”) at Desa Damansara Condominium (the alleged scene of crime) on 26th June 2008, he had locked and or latched the door to the Unit, from the inside, after he had allegedly entered into the Unit. His testimony is reproduced below:
S: Bukan sampai,selepas kejadian apa yang dikatakan tadi?
J: Saya sampai, masuk, saya lock pintu. Jadi semasa saya dalam rumah …..
S: Lock from inside?
J: lock from inside
S: Main door bukan?
J: Ya the main door
S: That was the beginning isn’t it?
J: Ya the beginning
S: It was latched from inside?
S: Latched from inside isn’t it?
J: Kunci ya ”
– It is submitted that this is a blatant lie and cannot be true because later, on further examination (in chief), PW1 testified that after the alleged sodomy, DSAI and he proceeded to the dining hall and drank “3 in 1 coffee” and ate curry puffs, which was apparently placed on the dining table. The million dollar question that is not answered by PW1 is: how did the “3 in 1 coffee” and the curry puffs find its way into the unit (mysteriously) when the main door to the Unit, in PW1’s own words above, was latched and or locked from the inside? If the door was latched from the inside, there is no way anyone could have had access into the Unit, to deliver the “3 in 1 coffee” and the curry puffs, unless PW1 engaged the services of the infamous -David Copperfield.